Overview
ABSTRACT
In this article we propose to frame the issue of expansion of digital technologies and their applications with respect to their ecological implications. We show that this sector is facing critical choices, being on a trajectory hardly compatible with net zero emissions targets set at both French and European levels, and a source of mismanaged wastes. We point the main relevant regulations and their limitations. We conclude that following a “digital sufficiency” is necessary.
Read this article from a comprehensive knowledge base, updated and supplemented with articles reviewed by scientific committees.
Read the articleAUTHORS
-
Fabrice FLIPO: Engineer, Professor of philosophy of technology - LCSP/Université de Paris, Institut Mines-Télécom, Evry
-
Jacques COMBAZ: Computer Research Engineer - Grenoble Alpes University, CNRS, Grenoble INP, VERIMAG, Grenoble
INTRODUCTION
Digital technologies are now ubiquitous, as illustrated by the fact that the French trade association for the sector, Numéum, includes companies working in almost every economic sector. But what are the ecological implications of such activity? This five-part article attempts to shed some light on the issue. The first part explains what digital technology is, and the dynamics behind its emergence. Digital refers to the so-called "Von Neumann machine" developed in the 1940s, consisting of a processor, a memory and an interface. It performs two main functions: informing and controlling. It therefore transforms public spaces (of all sizes) as well as machine control and logistics chains. The second part documents the main ecological implications of this evolution. The digital sector is consuming increasing quantities of materials and energy. Without a political decision, its greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions could double or triple by 2050. What can we do about it? The debate is generally organized along three lines: greening digital technology ("green IT"), using digital technology to green other sectors ("IT for green"), and demonstrating sobriety. The third section describes the three main regulatory responses aimed at making digital technology "greener": energy efficiency, the circular economy aimed at recovering materials, and the elimination of toxic substances. As it turns out, they do not constrain digital expansion. The fourth part looks at indirect implications. Do they really facilitate the "greening" of other sectors? On the contrary: digital technology enables economic growth, which in turn increases ecological implications, notably GHG emissions. Reasoning to the contrary (particularly from industry) is flawed on one key point: the dynamics of use. They imagine trajectories that would break with historical trends, without explaining how such a bifurcation would occur, or under what kind of reorientation of industrial investments. The inconsistency is obvious. This section clarifies the concept of the "rebound effect", often used in this debate. It refers to cases where local gains in efficiency are wholly or partly offset by the indirect implications of the policies pursued. The final section looks at future prospects, i.e. the main scenarios that have been developed to anticipate possible trajectories. The general conclusion is that the current dynamics of digital deployment at both global and national levels are seriously complicating both the achievement of GHG reduction targets under the Paris Agreement, and the ecological and social transition.
Exclusive to subscribers. 97% yet to be discovered!
You do not have access to this resource.
Click here to request your free trial access!
Already subscribed? Log in!
The Ultimate Scientific and Technical Reference
KEYWORDS
GreenIT | digital | ecology | sufficiency
CAN BE ALSO FOUND IN:
Home IT Digital documents and content management Digital technologies and their global responsibilities - An assessment
Home Innovations Eco-design and sustainable innovation Digital technologies and their global responsibilities - An assessment
Home Innovations Technological innovations Digital technologies and their global responsibilities - An assessment
Home IT Networks and Telecommunications Digital technologies and their global responsibilities - An assessment
This article is included in
Software technologies and System architectures
This offer includes:
Knowledge Base
Updated and enriched with articles validated by our scientific committees
Services
A set of exclusive tools to complement the resources
Practical Path
Operational and didactic, to guarantee the acquisition of transversal skills
Doc & Quiz
Interactive articles with quizzes, for constructive reading
Digital technology faces up to its global responsibilities
Bibliography
Exclusive to subscribers. 97% yet to be discovered!
You do not have access to this resource.
Click here to request your free trial access!
Already subscribed? Log in!
The Ultimate Scientific and Technical Reference